Lamp Selection
When deciding how to light an
object or area we normally start by selecting the best lamp to do the
job – not the fixture. The type of lamp will determine the amount of
light, the beam spread, the lamp life, and even the color of light.
These are the parameters that we work with in designing a lighting
system. With scores of lamps available to us, there is usually a
solution for every situation. After selecting the lamp, we choose from
the fixtures that have been designed to work with that lamp.
The easiest lamps to
specify are for path, area, and deck lighting. Most of the fixtures used
for these areas are designed to be used with non-directional bare bulbs.
The fixture controls where the light is directed since these lamps
illuminate in 360°. The only lamp choice that you may have is the amount
of light if the lamp used by the fixture is available in more than one
wattage. Since the fixture controls the spread of the light, increasing
wattage increases the intensity of the light and not the area that is
lit. Selection of these fixtures is covered in the next section.
For other lighting
tasks, downlighting, uplighting, spotlighting etc., the problem becomes
a little more complicated. When designing to light a particular area or
object, we need to specify the lamp that will place the right amount of
light with a beam spread that only covers the target area and then find
a fixture that uses that lamp. To do this we need photometric data for
the available lamps. There are several sources for photometric diagrams
for various lamps. Many of the manufacturers for landscape fixtures
include this data in their fixture catalogs.
Using the photometric
charts is relatively easy.

Source: Kim Lighting
The charts above are
both for 35 watt MR16 lamps. The chart on the left is for a 20° spot
(SP) and the one on the right is for a 40° flood (FL). On the chart the
horizontal axis is the spread of the light beam in feet. The vertical
scale on the left is the number of feet from the lamp or fixture. The
scale on the right is the footcandles of luminance at that distance. In
these examples, both lamps produce a 4’ radius of light around the
center of the beam. However the 35MR16/SP (spot) produces that beam
spread at 20 feet while the 35MR16/FL (flood) has that same spread at 10
feet. In terms of light intensity, the 35MR16/SP produces 44 footcandles
at 8 feet and the 35MR16/FL produces 22 footcandles. Once we have
determined the area we need to light and the amount of light needed, we
can search through the charts of the various lamps until we find the one
that best meets our needs.
Another easy to use
source for this data is General Electric’s Light*Beams Software.
Although this program was obviously developed by GE to promote the use
of their lamps, there are charts with equivalent lamps from other
manufactures available from other sources. According to the GE product
description you can “Use Light*Beams to display the candlepower data for
any (GE) lamp you choose - Light*Beams will perform the simple point
calculations to tell you how much light will fall onto the surface as
either a candlepower curve or cone diagram. Select a lamp, define its
distance from a surface and its aiming angle with the surface, and
Light*Beams will do the rest. If you aren't sure which lamp to choose,
let Light*Beams help you. Light*Beams contains Lamp*Scout which will
identify lamps meeting your performance criteria.”
The next problem is
deciding how much light is needed on the object or area. We normally
work in the range from 1/10 footcandle to 5 footcandles. Why 1/10
footcandle? Well that is the approximate light produced by a full moon.
While you may not be able to read the paper by the full moon, most
people can move about safely with the light of the full moon. Low levels
of light do not produce glare or deep dark shadows which can make it
more difficult to see. Some other guidelines to consider when
determining the amount of light to project:
·
Age of the people using the
area is a factor. As we get older we loose some light sensitivity.
·
Typically 5 footcandles is
adequate to light an object or specific plant; however signs and house
numbers may require more light.
·
Task lighting may have to be
in the 20-50 footcandle range. Tasks like reading, playing games, and
others that do not include fine detail will require 20-30 footcandles.
Tasks like cleaning and fine detail work may require 50 footcandles or
more.
·
By national building code,
stairways must have a minimum of 1 footcandle as measured at each tread.
Experimentation may be
required to get the optimum level of light. Fortunately, most fixtures
will accommodate a range of lamps that will allow you to increase or
decrease the quantity of light by switching lamps. You need to consider
the possibility of needing a higher wattage lamp than originally planned
when designing the lighting circuits so that there is adequate capacity
on the wire used in that circuit. |